While shopping with her friend Anna (Scarlett Johannson), Mary (Drew Barrymore) looks Punky Brewster-esque in her pigtails and casual clothing. Her plaid, sleeveless top is from Steven Alan (shop a similar style from A.P.C.) and Michael Stars created her cardigan. Do like Drew and finish the look with a pair of cropped jeans and Converse sneakers.

Photo courtesy of New Line Cinema