i'm srry, but Lindsey lohan has no sex appeal.

I completely agree with Sarah.

I love that long blazer Marisa is wearing. Fab do you know where we can get one of those!?

Why does everyone always hate on Lindsay? I think she looks great...

I like the dress and the jacket. It's lilke a sexy t-shirt dress.
Eventhough it's flattering on Lindsay, she looks a mess.

I like the dress and the jacket. It's like a sexy t-shirt dress.
Eventhough it's flattering on Lindsay, she looks a mess.

yeah. stick figures having sex appeal? on what planet?

marisa looks lovely. she's not just wearing a dress, like lindsay is. she has style.

Marissa looks better. Lindsay legs are ugly!

Marisa looks very sexy.

Did Michelle Williams wear this same dress to a premiere or something recently as well? There was a picture of her on People.com and I think it's the same dress.

I don't like either.

Lindsay makes the outfit look so trashy, like she was photographed wearing that outfit after a long hard night of partying.

At least Marisa's version of the outfit shows some class.

what happened to lindsay lohan? she has gone so down hill - tomei pulls it off brilliantly

It looks like a diaper on Lindsay.

I voted Marisa, but only because Lindsay's right boob looks so much bigger and lower than the left... it's hard for chesty girls to wear a shape like that

Lindsay needs a cheeseburger

I like how Lindsay let the dress hold it's own - it is a very pretty dress! But I also like Marissa's combo - can't choose... I would love a long blazer like the one Marissa is wearing!

I think they both pull it off, but Marisa looks slightly better. Lindsay's TOO disheveled...

Marisa looks so cute in that jacket.

It looks sloppy on Lindsay. Marissa brings some sophistication to the look.

I'm loving the blazer thrown over! Adds sophistication and pulls the look together with those heels. Purrr.

eat something, please, lindsay?

I think Lindsay is working it.
She has attitude.

I feel bad for Lindsay... in every poll like this where it's her or Paris Hilton or Miley Cyrus up against a more "respectable" actress, of course everyone will pick the other one. I did vote for Marisa though because I like the blazer with the dress.

They both look great (it's an Alex Wang dress, hard to mess that up), but I prefer Marisa's blazer & shoes.
~Tamia

Marisa.

i love that each actress managed to make it their own, but i have to say that strangely enough, i like LL's take on it. it just looked great on her tiny frame (not that i'm condoning her tiny frame)

Lindsay looks better....

yay Im platinum!

Really? On Marisa it just looks like a regular old white body-con. Sure she's the classy choice but Lindsay totally rocks this one.

Marisa wins. Lindsay just looks nasty.

i'd have to say both! i love how marisa added blazer/coat though

although I hate her and I think she always looks like a drug addict, I actually prefer the way Lindsay wore it. I hate her hair and her face (haha) and her shoes, but I like it with the little necklace (I know that's not much). What I really don't like is Marisa'a blazer or the shoes - if only she had worn it like Lindsay with some better shoes (I absolutely detest peep toes), she would have lived up to my expectations (I absolutely adore her)...

lol
Wtf Comments abt Lindsay!
U = Jealous!
It looks perfect on Lindsay & she's not skinny at all
I agree on Equestriennechic