I like Ashley's and Heidi's.

I agree, i like Ashely's and Heidi's
Kirsten's doesn't flatters her eye shape .. it makes them look smaller, but her blue eyes do pop up

are their looks really that different? or is it just that they each have different eye shapes and so the same look - looks different on each woman.

To achieve this kind of look requires a steady hand and a great wet/dry liner. Has anyone tried BeingTRUE's eye definer in Obsidian? Amazing- pair it alone for a clean but well-defined eye or use it wet to really enhance and draw attention to.

I like Heidi's look better. But given the season of summer, I think it would be so much prettier for celebs to rock pale or nude colors! Many brands like Chanel, Clinique, Nars, MAC and Stila have come up with beautiful lighter shades for the summer, I think natural beauty is what will be hot this season!

I like Ashley's. Overly harsh lines remind me of 13 yr old girls doing their makeup for the first time.

These look like kohl rimmed eyes, not pencil but the real stuff...the one where you lay the applicator against your lower waterline, lower your top lashes, then pull it out.

ashley

Ashley's!

Never been a fan of heavy-looking liner.

ashley and heidi's eyes look great!

anyone know how to get ashley's eyes?

Isn't Heidi a little old for that look?

leslievanhoute--never heard of doing it like that but now i gotta try! doesn't it get in your eyes though?

I like Kirstens.

i like ashley's it really emphasizes her beautiful eyes

I think they're all a bit too heavy handed, but I do love me some black eyeliner

I do like the look. I learned at a photo shoot the most idiot proof way to get this look. She used a Maybaline Eye Brow pencil in black velvet sharpened to a very sharp point and then she softened it with a lighter to make it apply smoothly. After that she took a lipstick brush and set the liner with MAC black tied shadow. I tried it at home with no prob and went dancing in the Florida heat and it looked great all night! (FYI I can't even put on lipstick without several tries.

I think they all look like raccoons with blonde wigs on.

you need bigger eyes to pull that off, which is why ashley looks the best, followed by heidi, and a distant third being kirsten.

can you do a how-to on ashley's? I usually hate raccoon eyes, but I luv wing tips and I luv how hers is done. I always try and fail; help please...

mariserin- do a youtube search for guerlain eye kohl and there are a bunch of tutorials. HTH!

LOVE Ashley's look! Bella: Think we can do a "How-to" on her look?

Ashley's then Heidi.
There is such a thing as too much of a good thing...

OMG Ashley looks gorgeous in this photo, I like her eyeliner best.

Ashley and Heidi's look the best I think.

#1 Ashley! Runner Up: Heidi

I don't like ANY of them. If I HAD to choose one of the three, I would say Heidi. She looks good in everything she wears and the way she presents herself.

Ashley's looks the best out of the three, but I think they all went a little overboard on the eyeliner. They kind of look gothic to me.

it looks so great on natasha komis from paris hilton my bff... but... on some girls who wear it every single day, they look sooooo different when it's off. and it could be slightly unpleasing.

mary kate usually has load of lengthening mascara and coppery eyeshadow.

I love black eyeliner to glam it up. Ashely and Heidi seems to be my faves though.

Love Ashley's need a tutorial.