ScarJo hands down!

Mariah Carey shouldn't be put in the same sentence. She's a queen.

Mariah always tries too hard to be a diva. But I am not looking forward to another rose scent either...

How about NONE? They're both photoshopped to hell and back.
Scarlett's overprocessed hair looks horrible and Mimi seems to be trying to hold a fart in her ad.

mariah looks constipated in this ad, so scarlett wins for me.

I'll take anything over what Mariah does.

Why is Mariah's chin tilted up so high? Not v. flattering.

scarlett looks divine.
mariah.. well.. i'll have to agree with #5, she does look constipated

Scarlett, I'm afraid. Mariah has been photoshopped to hell - they've changed the proportions of her face and body, and she has different *teeth*, for heaven's sake! Plus, the pose in the Mariah shot is not flattering, especially when compared with the D&G photo...

Mariah Carey just doesn't look right in that ad.

while i'm not a big scar-jo fan, mariah's image and music has always made me want to throw up a little.

I think Mariah looks appalling tbh. Scarlett's face is beautifully flawless as per usual. Also I prefer Scar ad's colouring the bronze in Mariah's is way too over done in my opinion so it now just looks plain tacky.

Where's the option for neither?

Mariah looks like she's either trying to push out a stubborn fart, or hold one in.

Both ads look horrible. Too much photoshopping (Mariah's bee-like waist with disappearing dress drapery, Scarlett's huge head compared to her tiny shoulders and its unnatural position).

Neither. They both look washed out and photoshopped to death.

I don't like either, but Scarlett's is less boring and unoriginal - plus Mariah looks really awkward...

D&G perfumes are always good, so I naturally voted for Scarlett. But I am very curious to try the new Hugo Boss fragrance promoted by Sienna Miller. Anybody tried it?

no offense to all the fans, but mariah just became... kinda stale for me now. she's lost her vibe.

i love scarlett, she's gorgeous and she loves her curves the way it is, and i look up to her for that. she looks like a goddess.

i don't like either--they're both very typical perfume adverts. where is the creativity, people?

but, hey. at least scarlett doesn't look mildly constipated.

Both look like their waiting for a vampire to TAKE them...

I feel so bad for Mariah - that has got to be one of the worst camera angles for her face EVER. And the entire pose is just unflattering. I can't believe they let it go to print.

Mariah looks to airbrushed. Her look is just too artificial.

Mariah's looks a little bit like she was just falling onto some pillows--ScarJo's looks so romantic! it makes me want to try some of that perfume

mariah is in a very awkard pose.

i dont care for mariahs fragrents

Mariah looks weird.

that pose on mariah doesn't look good