what?! she does look like a racoon!

i cringe when i see pictures of her >.

but shes a kid so whatever

I much prefer the 'softer' look on the right, but then I guess that 'Rocker' edg-y look is fine for clubbing, etc!

ooops - sorry - I meant the SOFTER look on the LEFT, not right!

I like the softer. For her hair and skin tone she could go even softer.

Not really sure who she is (part of the demi-sleb glut of right now?) but neither are particularly pretty. That said, the one on the left looks better than the one on the right, where the extensions are doing her no favor either.

"Softly lined" my butt. They're both way too much for a 15 year old.

Neither. She's just too much.

What's wrong about looking like Robert Smith?

Touche, Diesdre. I do love Robert Smith.

Both are too much for a 16 year old girl.She wears way too much makeup.

Her makeup looks stupid either way. Less is more, Taylor!

She's not cute. She looks WAY better without bangs, but she's still Cindy Lou Who in an awkward growth phase.. only permanently.

Neither. She needs a makeover.

I agree, both are a little too much for a 15 year old. What ever happened to "less is more".

I don't have an issue with a young girl experimenting - obviously the younger you are, the less makeup you need or even ought to wear - but I can understand the fun of trying new and crazy things.
My problem is that she does look like a racoon and the makeup is not only aging but very silly-looking (no one; no matter their age; can pull off this look). I hd no problem with the "I'm a big bad angst-riddles 15-YEAR-OLD who thinks she's smart enough to move out and live on the streets because no one understands that I want to make clothes wah wah wah" black lids that she wore on the show last season because she still looked young and pretty and it flattered her eyes. this, however, is just ugly and makes her look like a drug addict...

haha the 1st comment is so funny.

she's 15! I'm 15! I only wear that much when it's for like halloween or a show!

Yeah, experiment (because I know I sure do)...but please, no extreme racoon eyes!

Ha she is going to look back at this when she is 25 and be like wow I was really trying hard to rebel! Especially if she looks at herself in photos next to her fellow cast members. She is young so she is trying to be so cool so tough.

My mom would've slapped the eyeliner off of my face at her age. Nevermind that though, that's the least of her worries when she's walking around in lingerie.

ehh she's having fun...i picked the look on the left, but i think the hair on the right is better! mash them together...

i'd like her better with a mask over her face. that eye makeup is not flattering, but i can't even picture her without it!

I voted 'softly-lined', but what she really needs is a good smack and a cleansing towelette. Wipe off that makeup! Jesus.

Her over bleached hair bothered me on the most recent episode of Gossip Girl, it doesn't pair well with her heavy makeup ( at least to my liking). I'm all for the dramatics and having fun with makeup and style but she's not looking as gorgeous as she can.

I like it. She looks like an 80's kid in the picture on the left. I know my dad would've had a cow if I wore that much eye makeup when I was 16, but taylor looks cute and next season, she'll move on and try some different makeup. I say let her enjoy the makeup drama right now.

I think the eye makeup of the left picture and the hair and foundation of the right. The short yellow bob is not flattering for her and makes her look older than 15!